The first question just gets a snort from Garrot. He won't even dignify that question with a verbal response! But his eyes do go wide at the notion that everyone dies this year, because if she's telling the truth and everyone dies when she dies, then if she lives and the world ends...? The Garrot-brand scowling negativity drops as easily as the Wizard's smirk returns, and he spends a moment staring at her and trying to process what bullshit scheme she's trying to pull.

Nope, that's too much guesswork and willingness to trust the person who destroyed his entire life, he's circling back to the first question.

"You're telling me that the past thirty-nine years, you've just been patching up the Knights and Princess down here behind the scenes?" He gestures out wide with his arms towards this weird room. "Or did they still die because you just decided not to do anything?!" At least he's grouchy again...?